Epic Fail by Amy Letts – A D&D webcomic

XD I'm vaguely reminded of my OWN comic here–the message being “I have need of you on Mysada”. (dies) Wow, apparently our mysterious message sending characters must have something in common! They're very to-the-point!

And, y'know what? Most comics start out a bit dodgy. I sure did! …Still am! You'll get better in a few months, just keep drawing. Okay? I know you've read some of my comic so this isn't quite spam!

I think it's funny. “You actually remembered I'm here!”

You know… he looks a lot like the Burger King guy. o_O

I like your panelling, by the way. It flows so easily from panel to panel, it's easy to read and understand what's going on. Can I be a little bit critical of your art?

1) Don't overdo the lineart in the hair. Honestly, your hair shading looks better on its own, without the black around it, and encasing it into lines isn't really improving the look, at least for the hair. Some things look better with lineart and I personally don't think hair is one of them, it's danged hard to ink hair. I think if you replaced the lines in the hair with just darker streaks of shading, it might look a little better. Because the hair shading already looks really nice as it is…

2) Eye shinies! More shiny!

I speak from personal bias when I say I like to see people play with the Photoshopping. And you have detailed shading under your lineart. Don't hold yourself back. Build on it. It's pretty and shiny.

Anyway, honestly, your people are fine. Better will only come with practice, and practice will only come with updating your webcomic. You have nothing to apologize for. Just keep at it. The panelling is smooth and understandable, it reads well enough–you provide satisfying pages that even make me snrk a bit. It's all cool. It looks fine. Just keep at it. ^_^

(snrks over the last panel again) “Good gracious!”

Your comments aren't even remotely like spam! I am a comment whore anyway… the more, the better.
Thanks for your detailed critique, it is really appreciated. You make good points which I will be taking on board. At some point I arbitrarily decided to colour the eyes simply… I forget why. I guess I’m really cheating myself out of something that adds life and soul to a character. Doh! You’re right about the hair as well; it looks really cool at the inking stage, then I add colour and it sucks :s More planning required!
cheers!

That was not a detail critique. >.> I was being short-winded there. I'm capable of saying quite a lot, sometimes. XD I just don't do SURPRISE HUGELY DETAILED CRIT. And I wouldn't do that to a new comic, either, because I'd rather see you keep going than getting hung up on some comment I made and going all NO UPDATES UNTIL I GET IT RIGHT and going on INFINATE HAITUS or anything like that.

Anyway, lineart and soft shading don't really go together that well, unless you're doing it 'right', which is hard. (Which is why I don't ink) I'd rather see you play with going inkless for the hair, myself. I just feel that hair is too rigid looking when confined to a few lines like you're inking it. Flowy. Etc. Flail.

And yep, eyes add life and souuuul to a character. Souuuuuuuls. (crashes into panel borders) Braaaaains.

Lineart's just hard to get right, and even harder for hair. x_x

Weekly updates. (shakes fist) Oh well.

So. What is the king's name, and the name of his kingdom?

You’re so thoughtful  Yes, we artists can be a sensitive bunch at times XD
I do the line art on paper and the colouring in photoshop. That might explain why they don't fit together so well. Inking is my weakest area. My Mother does it so beautifully! I wish I had inherited that talent!
I’m doing a Valentines Day Special, so there will be an extra page that week (yay) though it will not be part of the story. I might experiment with colouring it differently.

King Geoff of the Barrier Kingdom.

Great comic! Teleporting Thrones would come in a handy!

Thoughtful. (snrks) As I said, I'm normally very long winded. Your lineart would be better if you went over it a few times to add line varience in places.

I'm biased to my own art style when I say I like your coloring better, though. I just… you know… like… colorful stuff. Not that I don't like inking. I do! I just generally like painty stuff better! COLOR! But yeah, fitting together hand inked stuff and Photoshop color can be a bit tricky, you might find it's easier to digitally ink… okay, I hate digital ink, but you might. Who knows. Hand coloring inks just takes too long. =( Are you hand inking your speech bubbles too? (peers at them) (I thought you were digitally inking, to be honest!)

And yes, a teleporting throne would come in handy.

This is very good what you have here. An entertaining story and bautiful artwork. Very nice job.

Yeah, the speech bubbles are hand-inked too. For me it is quicker, I'm just more confident drawing on a piece of paper.

Yoru needs you? Who is Yoru? See, now you've sucked me in and I must read more because I am a sucker for a cryptic message.